In our previous article, we showed what the end of the Flemish CHP certificates means for the sites that rely on them. The CHP is profitable in fewer hours, it has to be run far more consciously, and in most cases a suitable one-on-one replacement does not yet exist. That leaves an obvious question: what should a site do with its CHP? In this article, we explain how we approach that question with our clients, as part of an energy investment roadmap that links decarbonisation goals to contract structures, investment budgets and an economically viable operating cost.
Such a roadmap sets out which investments the site makes, and in what order. The CHP is one piece of that puzzle: whether it stays, and what role it plays, depends on what is built around it.
Two axes: flexibility and optionality
To decide which investments belong in the roadmap, we assess the energy system of the site on two axes: flexibility and optionality.
Flexibility is the ability to shift consumption or production to cheaper hours within a day, a week or a month. Switching between energy sources counts too: a hybrid installation, where a gas boiler and an e-boiler feed the same process, can be just as valuable. Flexibility can be bought, with a battery or thermal storage, but the cheapest flexibility is the one already hiding in your processes. Can a process be delayed? Can a building be pre-heated at night? Can the electric vehicles in the car park charge at lower power?
Optionality plays out over the longer term. A system with high optionality has several ways to meet its energy needs, which makes it naturally hedged against how energy prices evolve. The same hybrid installation is a good example: its owner can switch between gas and electricity, depending on the price difference between them. If electricity prices fall faster than gas prices, as we expect, the site can gradually consume more electricity and lower its energy costs over the years.
A CHP offers little flexibility, but real optionality
A CHP converts gas into heat and electricity. Most sites run it heat-driven: the heat demand of the process sets the output, and electricity is the by-product. That electricity is consumed on site, and any surplus is exported to the grid. Every MWh consumed on site avoids transmission and distribution tariffs and lowers the off-take capacity the site needs. For every MWh exported, the electricity price at that moment decides whether the CHP runs "profitably": does the electricity pay back part of the gas it burned?
As such, a CHP is not flexible. Everything depends on the process it feeds. If the process needs an exact amount of heat that only the CHP can deliver, there is no flexibility at all. If the CHP has headroom that the process or a buffer tank can absorb, it can be run flexibly.
Its optionality is the more interesting part. A CHP partially hedges the site. It produces electricity behind the meter that would otherwise have to be bought on the market, and sells it when the site does not need it. Horticulture is a good example. When crops such as roses or tomatoes need lighting, the electricity is consumed directly. When they do not, it is sold and earns extra revenue. And if gas prices rise, electricity prices rise with them through the clearing price, which dampens the losses.
So should you get rid of it?
That depends on the CHP and on the energy system around it. In the long term, the answer is clearly yes. Over the next 10 to 15 years, however, electrification will be a gradual journey, and large gas-fired units will remain the backbone of the electricity grid. The link between gas and electricity prices will remain, even if it holds less often. That ensures the optionality of a CHP behind the meter remains valuable.
Our advice to clients is therefore to keep the CHP, even after the certificates end, but to start building a system in which it plays a smaller role.
On the flexibility side, the starting point is the processes already on site: which of them can be shifted in time? Where that is not enough, investments can add more, with heat storage on the thermal side or batteries on the electric side.
On the optionality side, the answer lies in new production assets around the CHP, which also help to meet carbon reduction goals. An e-boiler, a heat pump or mechanical vapour recompression (MVR) are all candidates. Which ones fit depends on the heat demand, the required temperatures and the heat streams already on site. When electricity is cheap, which will happen more and more often, the site produces its heat with these electric assets. When electricity is expensive, the CHP takes over and produces both the heat and the electricity the site needs.
Because we expect electricity prices to become less correlated with the gas price, part of this shift will happen by itself, as long as the site follows its economic optimum day by day.
How we build the roadmap
Every site is different. That is why the first, and by far most important, step in building a roadmap for the site is to get a firm grip on what happens behind the meter: which processes run when, how much flexibility they hold and how they are linked. We capture this in a digital twin of the site that covers every energy carrier, from heat to electricity and gas, and takes every constraint into account. We feed it with historical data and future expectations, so that it covers the next 10 to 15 years.
Next, we simulate what could change. We build variants of the site that electrify certain processes, add solar panels, a battery or thermal storage, or combine these. Each variant is run against an envelope of scenarios, covering different climate years and different paces of electrification and renewable build-out. That shows what each variant costs and how much risk it is exposed to. The goal is not a plan that works well in one future, but one that also limits the risk in the others.
The same simulation yields the expected future emissions of the site. In practice, the exercise often runs the other way around: a company has an emission reduction target, say 65% lower by 2040, and needs a roadmap that matches both that ambition and its CAPEX budget. Once the plan is in place, the company sees what its ambition will cost, in CAPEX as well as in OPEX.
Two axes, one roadmap
Every decarbonisation roadmap that turns an emission target into a concrete plan should be built on two axes: flexibility and optionality. A flexible system may offer optionality and vice versa, but the two are not the same, and each deserves its own attention.
Companies that invest with both in mind prepare for a low-carbon future while keeping their strategic agility along the way. They take control of their energy transition, instead of undergoing it.
About Besso Energy
Besso Energy was founded by two former Elia engineers to help industry master its energy complexity. Besso OS, the first strategic energy orchestration layer, gives industrial companies one model of their site: the process, the assets, the contracts and the market, and what each of them is worth, in the next hour and over the next decade. It turns that model into actionable insights, links production planning to energy sourcing, and grounds every strategic analysis in the company's own numbers.
Companies that work this way see what each decision is worth before they make it, and take each next step of the transition on their own terms, not on those of their counterparties. We do not believe complexity behind the meter can be avoided. We believe successful companies keep grip on it and take part in it deliberately.
