Every MWh on your energy invoice carries two prices: the price of the energy itself, and the price of the risks your supplier takes off your hands. That second price is an insurance premium. Some of that insurance is worth every euro. Some of it covers risks your factory could carry itself. In this article, we go through the three risks a supply contract covers: price, shape and imbalance. For each, we show when it is worth carrying yourself, and what that takes.
The risks your supplier carries
When a supplier sells you electricity, it takes over a set of risks that would otherwise be yours. For each one, it charges what it expects the risk to cost, plus a premium for the uncertainty around it. Three of those risks you can take back by choosing a different contract. You then save the premium, but you pay what the risk actually costs you, and that is only cheaper if you manage it well. Other costs, such as credit risk, collateral and trading fees, stay with the supplier in every contract.
| Risk | What it covers | Can you carry it yourself? |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Prices move before the supplier has bought your volume | Partly: you cannot influence the price level, but you can hedge it yourself |
| Shape | Your consumption is not flat, while the market sells flat blocks, and it may turn out more expensive than expected | Yes, and flexibility can lower it |
| Imbalance | Your deviations: whatever you consume more or less than was bought for you, per quarter-hour, is settled at the imbalance price | Yes, if you forecast per quarter-hour and correct within the day |
These three risks are not alike. The price level is set by the market, and no factory can influence it. That is the risk worth insuring, although a fixed price is neither the only way nor the cheapest. Shape and imbalance follow from how your own site runs: when it consumes, and how closely it follows its plan. Your supplier can only estimate that from your past consumption, and it charges a premium for what it cannot know. You know your production plan, and with flexibility, you can change it. That is why the premium for shape and imbalance is often more than these risks would cost you, if you manage them well.
Your contract decides which risks you carry
How many of these risks you hand over depends on the type of contract. The three common types form a ladder: each step down hands more of the risk back to you.
At the top, a fixed-price contract hands all three risks to the supplier. You pay one price per MWh for the whole contract period, whenever you consume, as long as you stay within the agreed volume. The supplier builds price, shape and imbalance risk into that single number.
A contract indexed to the day-ahead price keeps most of that risk with you. You pay the day-ahead price of every quarter-hour in which you consume, plus a fixed adder. If prices rise, or if you consume in expensive hours, you pay the difference yourself. What the supplier still covers is imbalance: the gap between the volume it bought for you on the day-ahead market and what you actually consume. The supplier settles that gap at the imbalance price, which can be far above or below the day-ahead price.
With imbalance pass-through, that cost becomes yours as well. You pay the imbalance price on your own deviations. What the supplier still provides is, in essence, access to the market: it buys your energy, settles your deviations and invoices you. You pay a fee for that access and for the collateral and credit risk it carries on your behalf.
When carrying a risk yourself is worth it
Most large consumers have already moved down this ladder, often because their supplier moved them after the 2022 energy crisis. But moving down the ladder is not the same as choosing which risks to keep.
When you move down the ladder, you stop paying a premium, but you do not stop paying for the risk. You now pay what it actually costs, and that depends on how well you manage it. The supplier's premium is its own estimate of that cost, plus a margin. If you manage the risk as well as the supplier would, you save the margin. If you manage it worse, you pay more than before.
Whether that works depends on what the factory can do. Carrying price and shape takes a hedging policy for the price level, a reliable forecast of the plant's consumption per quarter-hour, and the ability to plan and adjust production against prices. Carrying imbalance on top of that takes the ability to correct deviations within the day. Those capabilities can sit with a team, in software or with an outside party, but they have to be in place before the risk is taken back. A factory that has none of them is better off paying the premium for now.
Day-ahead indexed: price and shape
On a day-ahead contract, you carry two risks that the fixed price used to cover: the level of the price, and the cost of your profile. They call for a different approach.
The first is the price level. On a day-ahead contract, you pay the market price for every MWh you consume. When prices rise, your whole bill rises with them. In 2022, the average day-ahead price was €245/MWh, against €104 the year before. For a factory using 20 GWh a year, that came to about €2.8 million extra. No factory can influence the price level, which is why it is the risk worth insuring.
A fixed price is not the only way to insure it. A hedge also locks in your price upfront, as we explained in an earlier article. The difference is that the shape risk stays with you. That is why a hedge costs less than a fixed price. One decision stays with you: how much of your volume to hedge, and when. That is what a hedging policy is for.
The second is your profile. You now pay what your hours actually cost, so a site that runs into the expensive evening hours pays more than the average price. Unlike the price level, this is something you can act on. Doing so requires a forecast of your consumption per quarter-hour and the ability to plan it against the next day's prices: moving flexible processes into the cheap hours, or switching between gas and electricity. The gains can be large: on an average summer day in 2025, a MWh at 20:00 cost about €120 more than one at 13:00. The risk is that you cannot move when it matters. If the evenings get more expensive and a factory keeps running into them, its profile gets more expensive too, and nobody covers the difference.
Carrying both risks yourself saves you the premium for price and shape. The risks themselves are now yours: you pay what they actually cost. With a hedging policy and daily planning, that can be less than the premium, and shifting consumption earns on top. Without them, it can be far more. That work has a cost too, whether you do it yourself or outsource it.
Imbalance pass-through: your deviations as well
With imbalance pass-through, the cost of your deviations becomes yours as well. Planning the day ahead is no longer enough. You also have to manage the plant during the day itself. Doing so requires three things: a reliable forecast per quarter-hour, a way to notice quickly when consumption deviates from it, and flexibility in your system that you can use to correct.
The saving is less certain here. The imbalance premium reflects what the supplier expects your deviations to cost. The supplier has an advantage, though. It can offset your deviations against those of its other clients, so the same deviations cost the supplier less than they would cost you alone. Pass-through only pays off if your forecast is good enough to beat that. The imbalance price can swing by hundreds of euros per MWh from one quarter-hour to the next, so a forecast that is consistently off gets expensive quickly. For a site that forecasts well, pass-through also brings an upside: deviations that help the grid are paid instead of charged. A site that can react to the state of the grid within the quarter-hour can turn its flexibility into revenue there too.
In short, the right contract depends on what your site can manage. A site with a stable baseload and little flexibility is well served by a fixed price on most of its volume. A site that plans production against prices every day belongs on a day-ahead contract, with a hedge for the level. Only a site that also has the flexibility to correct its consumption within the day gains from imbalance pass-through. Most sites should move down the ladder as fast as their capability grows, and no faster.
Cover is a choice, not a default
Choosing between a fixed price, a day-ahead contract and imbalance pass-through is choosing which risks you want someone else to carry, and what you are willing to pay for that. The answer is different for every site, and it changes with every battery, e-boiler or flexible process the site adds.
The companies that get this right compare each premium with what it would cost them to carry that risk themselves. They insure the level of the price, carry the risks their site can manage, and build or buy the capability to manage more of them over time.
About Besso Energy
Besso Energy was founded by two former Elia engineers to help industry master its energy complexity. Besso OS, the first strategic energy orchestration layer, gives industrial companies one model of their site: the process, the assets, the contracts and the market, and what each of them is worth, in the next hour and over the next decade. It turns that model into actionable insights, links production planning to energy sourcing, and grounds every strategic analysis in the company's own numbers.
Companies that work this way see what each decision is worth before they make it, and take each next step of the transition on their own terms, not on those of their counterparties. We do not believe complexity behind the meter can be avoided. We believe successful companies keep grip on it and take part in it deliberately.
